Colin Robinson

The emerging generation throughout the world, represented by people like Disha Ravi and Greta Thunberg, have shared concerns that cut across differences between nations and classes. “Workers of the world unite” was a great slogan for the 19th and early 20th centuries. Today it’s a case of young people of the world uniting, supported by older allies. Not for dictatorships of the proletariat, but for new forms of democracy based on mixed economies and renewable energy.

The Earth may be some kind of rare, but is it a kind of rare that rules out life and intelligence on other worlds?

You say Earth has "just the right combination of elements". Yes, the combination of elements found on Earth is just fine for the forms of life that have emerged on Earth... How could it not be?

Even in this solar system, there may be one or more other worlds that have just the right combination of elements for something that lives there. After we've had a better look at worlds like Europa, Enceladus, and Titan, not to mention Venus, we'll likely be in a better position to assess how abiogenesis and evolution can or can't work on the planets and moons in other systems.

Very good article! Taking the word "whore" in its literal sense, as a woman who has provided cuddles-for-cash, we have one in an Australian state parliament. Her name is Fiona Patten, she's a Member of the Legislative Council in Victoria, and she's neither secretive nor apologetic about the aspect of her CV I've just mentioned. She's published a book entitled Sex, Drugs and the Electoral Roll: My unlikely journey from sex worker to Member of Parliament. Fiona Patten is a political ally of Victoria's Premier, Dan Andrews, and has recently drafted a major reform of Victoria's prostitution laws. Is she an "epic whore"? I think yes... I mean, whatever you think about her policies, there is surely something epic about her forthrightness.

"So far, about 4,000 planets have been discovered outside the Solar System, none of which have had life on their surface." How much do we actually know about those 4,000 planets? What are the grounds for saying that none of them have life on their surface?

I'm not convinced that "there is a 'universal' language: mathematics and physics".

Physics (as we know it) is a way humans talk to humans about our own activities, as well as about the universe in general.

Dolphins, like humans, are hunters of fish. Yet, as you've mentioned, we've so far been unable to understand dolphin communication.

A smart life-form on another planet might do various other things that humans do, including (for instance) reducing silicon dioxide to elemental silicon in order to then do something with the silicon.

But would that necessarily mean we could understand the way they talk to each other about what they are doing?

Colin Robinson

Colin Robinson

Someone who likes sharing factual information and fragments of the big picture